Skip to content

FFAW-Unifor Rebukes Oceana Canada's Continued Misrepresentation of Mackerel and Capelin Fisheries

August 8, 2025

The Fish, Food and Allied Workers Union (FFAW-Unifor) strongly condemns Oceana Canada’s ongoing campaign to undermine the sustainable and economically critical mackerel and capelin fisheries, and is calling on the Department of Fisheries and Oceans (DFO) to exclude groups like Oceana from the stakeholder advisory tables. 

“Oceana’s latest attack on the mackerel and capelin fishery once again demonstrates their disregard for the realities faced by rural coastal communities and the professionals who steward these resources. Their narrative, driven by outdated data, misleading assumptions, and ideological extremism, seeks to shut down fisheries that are sustainably managed, tightly regulated, and vital to local economies,” explains FFAW-Unifor President Dwan Street. 

Despite Oceana’s claims, the Department of Fisheries and Oceans (DFO) moved capelin from the critical to the cautious zone in 2024, acknowledging improved biomass levels. Yet Oceana clings to outdated figures to fit their predetermined narrative.

In taking aim at the Atlantic mackerel fishery, Oceana has ignored the extensive, firsthand knowledge of inshore harvesters. Fish harvesters with decades of experience on the water have reported a resurgence of mackerel stocks, including widespread presence of juvenile and spawning fish across Newfoundland and Labrador, which paint a very different picture than Oceana’s doomsday narrative. FFAW-Unifor maintains its firm opposition to the ongoing moratorium and limited bait fishery for Atlantic mackerel. The decision to close the commercial fishery is out of step with the reality harvesters are seeing on the water.

“Oceana Canada has no direct connection to these fisheries. They do not hold licences, they do not process fish, and they do not contribute to local employment or the rural economy. Their offices are far removed from the realities of coastal Newfoundland and Labrador, yet they attempt to dictate policy from a distance without accountability, and without the lived experience of the people whose futures hang in the balance,” Street says. “Oceana’s aggressive campaigns seem less concerned with the health of our coastal waters and more aligned with maintaining funding and appealing to donors who have no connection to Newfoundland and Labrador or its inshore fishery. While fish harvesters fight to sustain rural economies and preserve their communities, Oceana appears more interested in preserving its brand and fundraising goals,” says Street. 

FFAW-Unifor calls on DFO to prioritize science-based decision-making and genuine stakeholder input that must come from those who live, work, and depend on the fishery.

Dr. Erin Carruthers

Dr. Erin Carruthers is the Science Director and Senior Fisheries Scientist with the Fish, Food and Allied Workers Union (FFAW-Unifor), which is the labour union that represents the owner-operator fleet in Newfoundland and Labrador. The FFAW is committed to research and management that supports healthy oceans, fisheries, and coastal communities. Dr. Carruthers received her Ph. D. in Biology from Memorial University in 2011 followed by a postdoctoral fellowship with the Centre for Fisheries Ecosystems Research. Before coming to Newfoundland, Erin worked as a Research Biologist with Fisheries and Oceans Canada at the St. Andrews Biological Station. Her current research program is co-constructed with fish harvesters and includes research on coastal fishing communities, collaborative longline and trap surveys, and best practices for the avoidance, handling and release of unwanted catch.